You are not currently logged in. Please create an account or log in to view the full course.
Opening Shots: A Nazi Massacre, August 1941
- About
- Transcript
- Cite
Germany – The Holocaust, 1939-45
In this course, Dr Mark Levene (University of Southampton) considers the Holocaust through a pan-European perspective. In particular, he argues that while Hitler and the Nazis were the primary driving force determining the fate of European Jewry, without considering the role of other Europeans we lack a sufficient explanation. European anti-Semitism had deep, primarily Christian roots and we need to understand something of why this was still active, indeed virulent in increasingly secular 20th century societies. He goes on to consider the nature of anti-Jewish hostility in specific countries, with Romania one key example, and how this helped shape cases of active and autonomous Jewish extermination regardless of any direct German diktat. He also considers the ambivalent role of liberal states such as France, Britain and the United States who certainly failed, possibly wilfully, to engage with an emerging Jewish refugee crisis before the Second World War. It is the issue of refugees - and the abiding problem of what happens when one country, then another, passes the buck - which is the warning note upon which course ends, seeking as it does to consider not just Jewish but universal legacies of the modern world's most all-encompassing genocide to date.
Opening Shots: A Nazi Massacre, August 1941
In this module, we think about the first five-figure mass murder in the history of the 'Final Solution', the massacre of some 23,600 Jews at Kamenets-Podolsk in the Soviet western Ukraine. In particular, we focus on the nationalities of the Jews who were killed, the majority of whom were not Soviet, or from the local area but were human beings who had been rendered 'stateless' by countries other than Germany, and to which they were entitled to citizenship. What does this tell us about other Europeans and the Holocaust?
Kamenets-Podolsk.
00:00:03A place in the Western Ukraine but one
00:00:06you're very likely not to have heard of.
00:00:08Well, I'm going to stop this course
00:00:12by talking about what happened here at the end of August,
00:00:141941.
00:00:18There was a three day massacre of Jews at this place between--
00:00:20in the Soviet Union, but very close to the Romanian--
00:00:26so the Hungarian, so the former Czech borders,
00:00:30and the Polish border too.
00:00:33In this massacre, something like 24,700 Jews, men, women,
00:00:37and children were massacred.
00:00:43And for those of you who know something
00:00:46about the early stages of The Final Solution, some of this
00:00:47will be very familiar to you.
00:00:51There were SS troops involved, though not very many.
00:00:54There was an order police battalion, number 320
00:00:58to be exact, who were just ordinary policemen who
00:01:02had been drafted to be to be there as order policemen,
00:01:05as reserve policemen in Russia.
00:01:10There were some auxiliaries as they
00:01:13were called, Ukrainian auxiliaries, because this
00:01:16is the Ukraine, and these are people
00:01:19who are drafted in very rapidly to participate
00:01:20in this particular exercise.
00:01:23And then there was somebody who is
00:01:27known in the annals, the notorious annals
00:01:30of The Final Solution.
00:01:34In fact, recently he's been called
00:01:36the outstanding entrepreneur of violence.
00:01:38He's a man called Friedrich Jeckein.
00:01:41And if you like, he's Himmler's right hand man
00:01:43who is specially requested at this particular point in time
00:01:47to come and oversee to supervise this particular destructive
00:01:53process.
00:01:59In fact, we find that he shows up at all sorts of places, all
00:02:00over the place in the course of Operation
00:02:04Barbarossa, the Nazi invasion of the Soviet Union.
00:02:07He appears after another massacre called Babi Yar
00:02:11a few months later.
00:02:15Later on, he's up in the north in the Baltic
00:02:16in Riga, where he organizes the massacre there.
00:02:19But this one is a special one, and it's
00:02:23recognized by most historians as being
00:02:26very significant for the very fact that it's
00:02:28the first time that there is a five figure
00:02:31massacre, in which not just a five figure massacre,
00:02:36but a five figure massacre of men, women, and children.
00:02:40So it's recognized as a major step
00:02:45change in the process, the cumulative process by which
00:02:49Jews begin to be massacred.
00:02:54And, of course, this process carries on
00:02:56through to the point where by the following year, already
00:02:59something like half a million Jews have
00:03:05been killed in the Soviet Union, in the course of Operation
00:03:06Barbarossa.
00:03:11However, there's something else which
00:03:13tends to get missed about this particular event,
00:03:17because the majority of the people who
00:03:21are killed in this destructive process come in hospitals
00:03:23are not local Jews.
00:03:29They are not even Soviet Jews.
00:03:31They are Jews who have come from across other borders.
00:03:34Some have come from Romania.
00:03:39Some have come from--
00:03:41in fact, the majority have come from Hungary.
00:03:43Though, actually, technically, they
00:03:46had previously been Czech Jews.
00:03:49And, of course, in 1938, and then into 1939,
00:03:53Czechoslovakia is partitioned and stops being Czechoslovakia.
00:03:58Most of it is taken by the Nazis, but then some of it
00:04:03is also taken by Hungary as well,
00:04:08and then there's an independent state of Slovakia is created.
00:04:10Now the interesting thing about the Hungarians,
00:04:14is that a lot of the people who end up on their territory,
00:04:17who formerly had been Czech Jews,
00:04:21had been living there for hundreds and hundreds of years,
00:04:23are determined by the Hungarian state not to be Hungarians.
00:04:28They are people who the Hungarian state
00:04:32says are stateless.
00:04:35And this means something very interesting.
00:04:37That they are people who are in effect,
00:04:40they have no citizenship, and the Hungarians
00:04:44feel that they can simply dump them somewhere else.
00:04:47There is also, by the way, a lot of Jews
00:04:50from elsewhere in central Europe who have also
00:04:52lost their citizenship.
00:04:55So they too find that they are in this stateless, refugee
00:04:56position.
00:05:02But they are not in control of their own destinies.
00:05:03What happens is, whether it's the Romanian state,
00:05:06or the Hungarian state, they are dumped across borders.
00:05:10And in this case, what is particularly shocking,
00:05:15is that they are dumped across a border into a war zone.
00:05:19So rather than coming out of danger,
00:05:24they are put into the immediate area of danger.
00:05:27And we end up with a sort of logjam at this obscure place,
00:05:31obscure to us, Kamenets-Podolsk, and the Nazis
00:05:35scratch their heads and say, what are we going
00:05:39to do with all these people.
00:05:41And they come to the decision, very rapidly--
00:05:43the SS comes to a decision very rapidly.
00:05:46We are going to get rid of them directly.
00:05:49And that's why you get Jeckein brought in.
00:05:54He is responsible for the massacre.
00:05:56These people are shot into pits in patches batches
00:06:00after batches for a period of three days.
00:06:04But what's important for us, is this is clearly
00:06:07not just about the Nazis.
00:06:11These people, as I said, are people who otherwise
00:06:14would be people seeking asylum.
00:06:17The Nazis eliminate the problem.
00:06:20But the reason there is a problem there
00:06:23at that point in the first place,
00:06:25is because the Hungarians and the Romanians
00:06:27have dumped them into this war zone.
00:06:30So this course is not just about Nazis.
00:06:33It's trying to work out why there is so much hostility,
00:06:36how much desire to get rid of Jews by other European states.
00:06:41
Cite this Lecture
APA style
Levene, M. (2018, August 15). Germany – The Holocaust, 1939-45 - Opening Shots: A Nazi Massacre, August 1941 [Video]. MASSOLIT. https://massolit.io/courses/the-holocaust-nazis-and-other-europeans-1939-45
MLA style
Levene, M. "Germany – The Holocaust, 1939-45 – Opening Shots: A Nazi Massacre, August 1941." MASSOLIT, uploaded by MASSOLIT, 15 Aug 2018, https://massolit.io/courses/the-holocaust-nazis-and-other-europeans-1939-45