You are not currently logged in. Please create an account or log in to view the full course.
The Historical Context: Race and Policing 1945-90
- About
- Transcript
- Cite
The Stephen Lawrence Case
In this course, Dr Anthony Gunter (The Open University) discusses the murder of teenager Stephen Lawrence in a racist attack in London on 22 April 1993, and why the case is considered a watershed moment in the history of race relations in Britain. In the first lecture, we set the context by exploring issues around race and policing since 1945, and especially the notion that BAME communities are “overpoliced and underprotected”. In the second lecture, we look at police malpractice during the investigation into Stephen’s murder and the Lawrence family’s fight for justice. Next, we explore the Lawrence Inquiry, commissioned in 1997, its recommendations, and its hugely important finding that the investigation into Stephen’s murder was marred by “institutional racism”. In the fourth and final lecture, we consider the legacies of the Lawrence Inquiry, including changes to the law and police practices, before tempering this by noting some persistent problems in the policing of BAME communities.
The Historical Context: Race and Policing 1945-90
In this lecture, we think about race and policing since the Second World War, and especially the idea that BAME communities are “overpoliced and underprotected”, focusing in particular on: (i) the impact of immigration policy on policing, including the death of Joy Gardner during a police raid on her home in 1993; (ii) the disproportionate use of stop and search powers on black communities and the tensions this has caused since the 1970s; (iii) police failures to protect BAME communities from racist violence, from the 1958 race riots to the New Cross fire of 1981.
Dr Anthony Gunter.
00:00:06Um programme Leads of childhood Studies a new
00:00:07study that open University senior lecturer um,
00:00:10also criminologist.
00:00:13Today we'll be talking about the Stephen Lawrence case.
00:00:15So the Stephen Lawrence case a watershed moment
00:00:18in Postwar UK history in relation to policing racism
00:00:21and has had a major impact in terms of our attitude towards policing uh,
00:00:27non white communities will be a semi communities.
00:00:33Today.
00:00:36We look at the context around race policing and immigration in the UK Um,
00:00:37since 1945 46
00:00:44then we'll look at the issue of racist violence,
00:00:47how that was or was not taken seriously by the police
00:00:51and how the murder of Stephen Lawrence, um,
00:00:55was to play a major role in how we looked at policing
00:00:59a regard to bme relationships and the police be how
00:01:03the police actually engaged with this issue around racist violence.
00:01:07The arrival of the S s Ren rush at the end of the 19 forties was to herald a
00:01:13great change in post war British society in terms
00:01:18of what we call the heralding of coloured immigration.
00:01:21In other words, large numbers of of non white, um,
00:01:24people from the Commonwealth,
00:01:28all the former colony itself from from the
00:01:31Caribbean from Africa and South Asian subcontinent.
00:01:33But of course,
00:01:36this was to have a profound impact on the majority of
00:01:37white population in terms of although these non white British citizens,
00:01:40because they were British citizens,
00:01:45were called to to work in the U K to work in Britain
00:01:46on arrival, they were to encounter a great deal of resistance, um, and violence.
00:01:51And of course, this has an impact in terms of, you know,
00:01:59are they protected by the police from this
00:02:03from this violence from the host white communities.
00:02:05So what we tend to find, according to uh,
00:02:08many academics and research is that
00:02:11black and Asian and minority ethnic communities
00:02:14have been over police whilst under protected by the by the law.
00:02:17And what we mean by this is is when we look at the the the the issue of of
00:02:22police racism or the policing of of non white communities,
00:02:28we tend to find high numbers of stop and search Destin, Destin,
00:02:33Destin police custody and other problematic community police relations.
00:02:37However, this group, as it became groups,
00:02:42have suffered a great deal of
00:02:46victimisation racing victimisation and racist violence.
00:02:48In this context of victims of crime,
00:02:52you'd think that the police would be there
00:02:54to protect them and investigate such issues.
00:02:57Unfortunately,
00:03:00this has not been the case.
00:03:01That's the first issue with regard to poor
00:03:04relationship between the police and the Amy communities.
00:03:07We can, firstly see this in relation to immigration itself.
00:03:10So we start to see this idea that these black and Asian
00:03:15we all should be sent back home to their countries of origin.
00:03:19So we have, of course, Enoch Powell's rivers of Blood speech in late 19 sixties
00:03:22because of the hostility that was that many black
00:03:27and Asian people faced in 1950 sixties onwards.
00:03:31The rise of the skin heads the National Front.
00:03:35You know, Powell was saying, we should keep these black people out,
00:03:38and if we let them come, their Children are going to cause mayhem.
00:03:42So what happened was the government became rather alarmed. And rather than protect
00:03:45these new arrivals, they actually pandered to the political right.
00:03:51And what they in fact did was they looked to
00:03:57stop black and brown people coming to the UK.
00:03:59So from 1971 immigration Act, this actually
00:04:02shifted the policing of immigration at the border to policing internally.
00:04:06And what I mean by that is police and immigration officials
00:04:11would start to raid properties of black and Asian people,
00:04:15their homes and businesses, their place of worship,
00:04:19their places of entertainment and ask them for their passports.
00:04:21Ask them for their papers.
00:04:25And this is because in 1971 Immigration Act actually
00:04:27put a great empathy emphasis on police and immigration service
00:04:31to actually ensure that black and brown people are not
00:04:35over staying their welcome or not coming here illegally.
00:04:39Because there were new situation whereby you had to have a
00:04:43grandparent that British before you could come to the UK,
00:04:48you also have to have work lined up.
00:04:52You had to have family. You had a certain amount of financial capital for you, too.
00:04:54Your family could then say Yes, we can support these persons,
00:04:59So there's many more things put in place to stop
00:05:02black and Asian people coming to the UK and settling,
00:05:06and the problem with many of their families were already here,
00:05:09having come in 19 fifties, 19 sixties.
00:05:11So what you would tend to see from the late 19 sixties and seventies onwards are
00:05:15the other family members of those who are already settled in the UK coming here.
00:05:20So, in fact, they were facing an additional burden.
00:05:24One of the main problems around this was some stories around deaths in custody.
00:05:28So if we fast forward to 2 to 1993 we see that Joy Gardner died a
00:05:33violent scuffle with immigration police officers who were
00:05:42trying to deport him back to Jamaica.
00:05:45So this actually called a great deal of outrage.
00:05:48But of course,
00:05:51this wasn't the only issue of violence that was meted out to
00:05:52those who were deemed to be over staying their welcome campaigning charities like
00:05:55Inquest to have been particularly concerned
00:05:59about disproportionate number of black and
00:06:02Asian people who have died in custody and not just police custody,
00:06:04but in terms of immigration,
00:06:08Young Offenders institute so that that's on on one level to be concerned.
00:06:10There's also the issue of Stop and Search stop,
00:06:15and search is an exceptionally contentious issue.
00:06:19It's an issue that's obviously you know, we're hearing what about today's news,
00:06:23but it goes back 40 to 50 years to the 19 seventies,
00:06:26allegedly the police used to go *** hunting in places like Brookstone.
00:06:30And in fact, if we look at the relationship between the black community
00:06:35and the police, we can we can pinpoint a number of flash points.
00:06:39So if we go back to the 19, I believe it was 1976. Um, what they called nothing.
00:06:43Hill works after nothing on carnival.
00:06:48Number of black young people basically attacked the police and and
00:06:51this was in response to the ongoing heavy handed discrimination,
00:06:57Uh,
00:07:00an oppressive practises that experienced from the police if we then
00:07:01far forward to the early 19 eighties so 1981 in Bristol,
00:07:05in Handsworth, in Birmingham, in in tax, different Liverpool in leaves,
00:07:10we see a number of flash points, what we call riots or uprisings,
00:07:15depending on on what side of the community fence you're sitting.
00:07:19But again, there are always sponsors too heavy handed policing, and in fact,
00:07:22in 1981 Brixton disorders was as a result of Operation Swamp,
00:07:27whereby the police would would swamp the
00:07:33Brookstone area looking for handbag snatchers,
00:07:36and you had up to 3 to 400 police harassing young black men, putting them into vans,
00:07:40beating them up, fitting them up.
00:07:47So there was.
00:07:49It was it was a real level of hostility and anger towards the police,
00:07:49which led to one of the most serious social
00:07:54disturbances on mainland Britain in over 100 years,
00:07:58which led, of course,
00:08:02to the Lord's Carmen Report and in fact has informed policing going forward.
00:08:03But within this,
00:08:09we also have to look at the issue of racist violence and
00:08:10how the police are not protecting the these black and Asian communities.
00:08:13So if we go back to 1958 when you know, uh,
00:08:18we start to see large numbers of black people are coming from the from the Caribbean.
00:08:22Around rush generation, there are a number of races,
00:08:26the first written within Nottingham but also race riots in Notting
00:08:29Hill and Camden and other other parts of the country.
00:08:34And what we mean by race works is that white people who were angry that black and
00:08:37Asian people are moving into these areas and
00:08:42so that an angry mob would would basically,
00:08:44you know, arrive and and start shouting, jeering
00:08:47and attack black and Asian people on the streets.
00:08:51And in 1959
00:08:551 year after the race rights.
00:08:57We also see that the murder of council Cochran arrest Indian man.
00:08:59Of course,
00:09:04this created a lot of alarm and disquiet within the immigrant communities and of
00:09:04course they look to the police to what will they do about it?
00:09:10But the police refused to accept it with a racially motivated attack.
00:09:13But of course we also need to put this in
00:09:17the context of racial violence over the past century.
00:09:18So at the start of the 20th century,
00:09:22also see race riots in Liverpool in Bristol again around
00:09:23lots of non white people settling in the dark areas.
00:09:28So we shouldn't just say it's an issue that has
00:09:32affected Britain in the post Second World War period,
00:09:34but it's actually been part of British history for the past 100 or so years.
00:09:37We also need to look at the rise of the National
00:09:42Front in the 19 seventies and 19 eighties who are far
00:09:46right organisation and we start to see a real growth or
00:09:49rise in actual violence meted out against second generation um,
00:09:53youth growing up, they've gone to school here, but more concerning Lee.
00:09:57We start to see attacks on the homes and businesses of
00:10:01black and Asian people throughout England and the United Kingdom.
00:10:05And a watermark case is what is in 1981 the
00:10:09new cross fire and some many in the community.
00:10:14We refer to it as a new cross massacre.
00:10:18Now, what this was was a house party with with with young black people, you know,
00:10:20playing their music and having a good time.
00:10:26But it was burned down.
00:10:28Now the community believed that it was This was racially motivated
00:10:30because there had been a spate of these arson attacks,
00:10:34friable attacks on black and Asian families, not just in south East London,
00:10:38but throughout London and throughout the country.
00:10:42So what? The community?
00:10:45We're asking for the police to take this seriously and to look into this issue.
00:10:46Of course, the police didn't
00:10:50
Cite this Lecture
APA style
Gunter, A. (2021, October 26). The Stephen Lawrence Case - The Historical Context: Race and Policing 1945-90 [Video]. MASSOLIT. https://massolit.io/courses/the-stephen-lawrence-case/the-lawrence-inquiry-and-the-macpherson-report
MLA style
Gunter, A. "The Stephen Lawrence Case – The Historical Context: Race and Policing 1945-90." MASSOLIT, uploaded by MASSOLIT, 26 Oct 2021, https://massolit.io/courses/the-stephen-lawrence-case/the-lawrence-inquiry-and-the-macpherson-report