You are not currently logged in. Please create an account or log in to view the full course.
5. Legacy and Critiques
About this Lecture
In this module we explore Berlin’s legacy and comment on some critiques of his work, focusing in particular on: (i) how Berlin’s distinction between two concepts of freedom was challenged by Gerald MacCallum; (ii) the reinterpretation of Berlin’s two concepts of freedom by Charles Taylor; (iii) the work of Quentin Skinner and Philip Pettit in subsequently establishing a third concept of liberty; (iv) the relevance of Berlin’s ideas after the end of the cold war; (v) we finish with a defence of Berlin’s distinction between positive and negative freedom, drawing directly on Dr Dimova-Cookson’s own work in her book “Rethinking Positive and Negative Freedom”.
In this course, Dr Dimova-Cookson (Durham University) explores the political ideas of Isaiah Berlin. In the first module, we give context to the life and works of Isaiah Berlin. Then, in the second module, we explore Berlin’s concept of negative freedom, before turning in the third module to compare this to Berlin’s notion of positive freedom. Here we think in particular about Berlin’s fear that positive freedom can lay the groundwork for legitimising political indoctrination. In the fourth module, we explore Berlin’s idea of value pluralism through contrast with monism, and comment on how Berlin could be seen as an exponent of multiculturalism. Finally, in the fifth module, we explore Berlin’s legacy and comment on some critiques of his work, before concluding with a defence of Berlin’s distinction between positive and negative freedom, drawing directly on Dr Dimova-Cookson’s own work in her book “Rethinking Positive and Negative Freedom”. This course may be particularly useful for those interested in the Liberalism and Multiculturalism aspects of the Core and Non-Core Political Ideas components of the AQA and Edexcel Government and Politics A Level.
Dr Dimova-Cookson is the Associate Professor in Political Theory in Durham University's School of Government and International Affairs. Her research focuses on moral and political issues in political thought, including the dual nature of liberty, justifications of human rights, moral development, value pluralism, ethical particularism versus ethical universalism, and multiculturalism. She recently published 'Rethinking Positive and Negative Liberty' (2020).
Cite this Lecture
Dimova-Cookson, M. (2022, April 06). Political Ideas – Isaiah Berlin - Legacy and Critiques [Video]. MASSOLIT. https://massolit.io/courses/political-philosophy-isaiah-berlin/legacy-and-critiques
Dimova-Cookson, M. "Political Ideas – Isaiah Berlin – Legacy and Critiques." MASSOLIT, uploaded by MASSOLIT, 06 Apr 2022, https://massolit.io/courses/political-philosophy-isaiah-berlin/legacy-and-critiques